James was last seen leaving the "Hideaway Club' at approximately 3:15am in the company of five individuals all of whom have been reported missing as well. All six individuals were traveling in a burgundy 1986 Chevrolet Caprice. The other individuals were found inside a car submerged in the Pea River in Coffee County, Alabama on September 29, 1999. Mr. Reynolds body was never recovered. Despite numerous searches of the river only a dark colored jacket believed to belong to Reynolds has been found.